Wishing and Fantasizing

Wishing wellAt the workshops I do with Faithful and True Ministries (for people struggling with compulsive sexual behavior), we talk a lot about the role of fantasy. We help people “take every thought captive,” not by trying to shut the thought out and make it go away, but by evaluating it, and trying to learn from it. When we look with sober and compassionate eyes at our fantasies, we find that they reveal hidden longings that often have arisen from unmet needs in our past. And when we learn ways to meet our needs in healthy ways, and work through the pain in our past, our fantasies lose much of their power.

This is true both of sexual and non-sexual fantasy. Many people have money fantasies (about winning the lottery, for example). Or sports fantasies. To this day, I find it hard to listen to certian types of music without fantasizing about being the musician on stage, playing the music I am listening to. These fantasies create scenarios where our desires for attention, esteem, security, and/or a host of other needs get met.

In my work as a coach, I also have come to see that fantasies can often be a barrier to healthy action. The more I fantasize about something, the less mental energy (and physical time) I have to devote to actually doing something about it. If I’m fantasizing about money, chances are I’m not doing the things I should be doing for my financial well-being. If I’m fantasizing about playing an instrument onstage, then I’m not working to develop my skills as a musician in real life.

All of this brings me to an extended, yet elegant, quote from Jim McGregor. Here’s what he says about wishing and fantasizing, and its role in recovery:

Wishing that I were someone else – more famous, wealthier, stronger, more beautiful, or more serene – is destructive to my well-being.

By changing my attitude of wishing and fantasizing to that of acceptance and gratitude, I will no longer be devastated by disappointments and losses.

Being famous, wealthy, strong, beautiful or serene is fine but not required for my well-being.

The reality of the present moment is my starting point. I can choose to let go and allow the growth process to begin, or I can continue to fantasize and stay where I am.

One thought on “Wishing and Fantasizing”

  1. Mark,

    One of the most difficult concepts to convey to an addict new to recovery or even his spouse is the idea that “fantasy is a window into your own soul.”

    Pastors, Biblical counselors and well meaning legalists take the Bible so literally about any glimpse of fantasy is sinful and that the sexual sinner must squash that thought from his mind.

    Qualified counselors like Dr. Mark Laaser can utilize the mental images into a roadmap towards wholeness and sobriety. One of my favorite illustrations is: “I cannot contorl the birds that fly over my head, but I can prevent them from building a nest in my hair.” The right question is: “Why did the birds chose to land there in the first place?”

    God bless,

Leave a Reply to Jerry Sinclair Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *